Skip to main content

A Surprising Request Regarding Float Night

150th Anniversary

While out of town for a weekend, Nancy Meneely ’65 was startled to receive a call from her posture picture photographer

Illustration by Shawn Prairie

BY NANCY MENEELY ’65

Published April 2, 2025

When I was a senior, I left Northampton for Vermont to spend the weekend with a would-be sweetheart, Wally, at his home, the first time I’d done such a thing. I’d hoped to keep this sojourn under wraps, but on Saturday afternoon the phone rang. Wally answered, raised his eyebrows. “It’s for you!” he said and handed me the phone. Horrified, I said, “Hello?” and waited for my mother to ask penetrating questions. But it was Miss Clute, my posture picture photographer, whom I liked nevertheless. 

She came directly to the point, asking whether I would agree to be the voice from the island for Float Night some weeks hence. Wholly unprepared for such an honor, I said, “But Miss Clute, why me?” She replied, “Because you’re the second funniest senior and Julie Goetz ’65 can’t make it.” Of course I said I would, and I did, aware every minute before and during Float Night that I had no idea what I was doing. But I got, and have kept, really lovely thank-you notes that came to Comstock House in the following weeks—one, of course, from Miss Clute. But how did she know I was the second funniest senior?

This is just one of the many love stories we've received in conjunction with Smith's 150th. Submit your own using our love story submission form.

Related Articles